Argument forms — The form of inference an ARG makes, and with it the critical questions that inference has to survive (Walton’s argumentation schemes). An ARG answers each question in its body or is objected to (ADR-032).
Cause to effect — this mechanism produces that outcome. Critical questions: is the mechanism operative here? Could a confounder produce the same outcome?.
1 of 52 ARG documents. Back to the full index.
| # | Title | Summary | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| ARG-020 v2 | The compensation hypothesis gives the mechanism by which a rendering keeps the act while changing the proposition | CLAIM-053 credited A24’s compensation hypothesis with the mechanism for the necessity half: a rendering can keep the act while changing the proposition. Rejected on CLAIM-229’s reply. The hypothesis says that lexical infidelity can be required for pragmatic fidelity, which is about words, and a change of wording can keep the proposition. | Rejected |